Madden NFL 23 Review

50 Comments

1. Early on they mentioned "Madden lagging behind it's Competitors." What games does Madden compete with?

2. Uhmmmmm "A series that consistently lagged behind its competitors" 0:30 What competitors, 2K5? SMDH

3. "Consistently lagged behind its competitors" It's literally been the only NFL sim since like 2005. It doesn't have competitors. WTF are we even talking about.

4. Bring back the tony Bruno show!

5. Jets fan here. That line hurt

6. A for effort this year but the game is still way off from the true footballs sim we all need.

7. Where’s the refs???

8. The only thing new this year is the character model of John Madden.

9. Remember when IGN had actual reviews of their games… Pepperidge Farms remembers…

10. Jets fan here. Didn’t expect to catch a stray in a madden review smh

11. IGN is for real on someone's payroll this game is more broken than ever wtf are they talking about. Unbelievable.

12. 1:01 are they referring to current gen as ps4? Ps5 been out for 2 years

13. Another 7

14. We will get a better Madden when 2k make it.

15. It’s 2022 an madden still haven’t topped nfl 2k smh

16. Honestly for me…it's not that horrible this year. I'm having fun with it so far. Till the 1st patch I'm sure lol but…Madden is Madden at the end of the day

17. Lol sooooooo wait til it's on gamepass and it's free? Got it

18. Until they fix the offensive line blocking assignments gameplay will be terrible.

19. It's always going "back to it's roots" and not actually introducing new creative additions to actually convince me that it's a full price game. Everything "new" is things that have been taken out and put back in like it never existed before the current game.

20. Please stop buying this franchise… it has become a lazy cash grab. When a game from 2004(2k5) still beats it…. They are taking football game fans for granted…stop letting them!

21. madden hasn't been relevant in over a decade. crappy games for a LONG time now. it's a shame what they did to this franchise.

22. MADDEN 23= A HUGE MASSIVE PILE OF

23. Franchise Mode L I’m out

24. Tired of madden

25. 3.41 : that action is pretty shocking IMHO !!!

26. You can't keep giving these games this generous of a rating. You guys need to give more honest reviews.

27. Ncaa 06 on my pa2!

28. I'll wait for Angry Joe, not surprised when in doubt IGN 7 it out

29. PC version is still not next gen. This is a 1/10

30. When 2k22 drops in October for 29.99 and ages like wine … Let's gooo ESPN

31. “Lag behind its competitors” ????

    WTF are you talking about?!?!? Madden had no competitors! EA has monopoly on NFL and that’s why they bring out same shitty reskin of the game every year

32. Can you guys please give up the licenses so 2K can give the fans what they want please

33. After all that you gave it another 7? Wtf

34. “For a series that has consistently lagged behind its competitors”…….what competitors? They are the only nfl game out there

35. wonder when the check cleared for them t do this review.

36. You know a franchise is done when its on the right path and only gets a score of 7

37. "a series that has lagged behind its competitors…" UMM….WHAT COMPETITORS?

38. Everyone else says differently.

39. A shocker!!! IGN giving a 7 to something…

40. We need another 2k football game so we get Madden to at least try to compete

41. A $70 glimpse of light at the end of a never ending frostbite engine tunnel.

42. Hasnt ign given madden a 7 out of 10 for the last 10 years?

43. A 2 would have been a gratious score.

44. It's a NO!! out of 10 for me.

45. The crowd reaction reminds me of the crowds during the first year of the pandemic! Still no refs on the field, sidelines look pathetic, there’s nothing that resembles football simulation. EA should look at All Pro Football 2K8 for real football simulation!

46. IGN Madden's protective shield.

47. For those of us who don't have the youtube dislikes extension, it is currently sitting at over 5K dislikes.

48. 7/10

49. "A series that's lagged behind it's competitors"? What competitors IGN? EA's NFL exclusivity deal has killed competition and thus any true innovation. This franchise has been stale, stagnant and boring for over a decade.

50. Whats funny is the criticism is fairly correct, but the verdict is bias.

Comments are closed.