The problem with IGN’s Sonic Mania Plus Review

27 Comments

1. They changed the title from: "Sonic Mania Plus Review" to "Sonic Mania Plus/Encore DLC Review". Idk if they saw my video or if they realised theirs wasn't clear enough, but this truly shows that they have grown from the whole "Sonic was never good" phase.

2. The problem with every review is that they exist in the first place, you don’t review paid dlc.

3. Assmad Sonic fan mad that a expansion pack of a romhack didn't get a 10

4. "Wahh a game reviewer gave a DLC a 7 they're stupid"

5. Opinions

6. I assumed the score was towards the dlc and not the previous released base game since it was reviewing the plus content and not that base game, which already was done.

7. It's just a 5 dollar expansion for an already great game. If you liked Sonic mania this dlc is definetely a must.

8. I dont understand why ign does this. I think they need to stop doing sonic reviews even if they put a good score in the review

9. I saw nothing wrong with it they did say it was just the dlc

10. Wow!? the person who did this play through on this video is great on the bonus stages!?????

11. the game is fucking shit. sonic fanboys never change smh

12. The only thing that I also don't like about this review is that they treat the game as if it was supposed to be a brand new experience, although the dlc is supposed to add replayability to the game, not a whole new game. The gameplay also looks very good, the new level design has removed all the annoying bus in the levels. For example the blocks in Chemical Plant now have a different pattern, so they don't crush you when you enter the drowning part and the section on the top seems way less challenging in a bad way. I obviously don't know what this is actually going to be like, but the arguments stating what is bad seem kinda weak. Especially when he says he doesn't like the special stages because they're hard.

13. Sonic was never bad…

    Ok, that is a lie

14. Okay.

15. FUCKign ignORANT

16. Russian people (except me) say that Sonic Mania is a unoriginal, copypasting cash-stealing mess, that it has nothing original, it's too simple for 2017 and most of 2017's platformers are alot better by their opinion. Do you agree with them? I don't.

17. Someone seems upset about a bad score again. Well it has been done and get over it.

18. I'm not even going to watch the video. I know that IGN will only give it a bad rating cause those people over at IGN don't have faith in Sonic.

19. Did you guys see sonic team's tweet mocking IGN, saying that there's still too much water in plus?

20. i think everyone knows ign are idiots… i dont bother with them much now days report to much on rumours. only facts they come out with has to be spoonfed to them

21. People have made this joke but… since Mania Plus is effectively DLC… the rating may be 8.5+7= 15.5/10

22. Lel i did some math and found out that both reviews mashed into one score would give a 7.8 out of 10

23. Are people really mad that IGN made another bad review? Because I am not…

24. I hidden

25. Too much Mania -IGN

26. The problem with IGN's Sonic Mania plus review… Is that it's an IGN review!

27. Stupid IGN. Sonic mania is a 10/10.